Skip to content

Comparison

Onion Mail vs. Proton Mail: private e-mail, encryption & anonymity

In short

  • Least KYC: Proton Mail (No KYC required).
  • Proton Mail has the best score (7.4).
  • Onion Mail leads in Control & account risk.
  • Proton Mail leads in Privacy, Encryption, Security, Trust, Costs, Features, Community.
Show

differs best value same for all

Attribute Onion MailOnion Proton MailProton
Overview Occasional KYC · no personal data No KYC · e-mail or wallet only
Score 4.2 7.4
Privacy 5.0 5.7
Encryption 5.0 9.4
Control & account risk 6.0 3.0
Security 0.0 10.0
Trust 5.4 9.7
Costs 0.0 8.0
Features 6.4 6.8
Community 0.0 6.4
Score factors that differ
Plus KYC policy Occasional KYC3 of 5 No KYC required5 of 5
Plus Data at sign-up No personal data3 of 3 E-mail or wallet only2.4 of 3
Plus Sign-up over Tor/VPN Allowed3 of 3 Allowed with an extra check1.5 of 3
Plus Monero accepted yes3 of 3 no0 of 3
Plus Cash accepted no0 of 2 yes2 of 2
Plus Legal seat United States1 of 5 Switzerland5 of 5
Plus Tor or I2P address yes · Tor (.onion)1 of 1 no0 of 1
Note Where mailboxes are stored not published yes · Germany, Norway, Switzerland
Plus Zero-access storage Provider holds keys5.5 of 11 Zero-access11 of 11
Plus End-to-end encryption OpenPGP2.5 of 5 Between users, OpenPGP5 of 5
Plus Encrypted subject lines not published0 of 1 no0 of 1
Plus Abuse handling Reviewed first3 of 6 Suspension on complaint0 of 6
Plus Two-factor login not published0 of 5 Authenticator app, Security key5 of 5
Plus Open-source apps not published0 of 3.5 yes3.5 of 3.5
Plus Security audit not sourced0 of 2.5 yes2.5 of 2.5
Plus Bug bounty programme not sourced0 of 1 yes1 of 1
Plus Operating since since 20260.57 of 4.5 since 20224.03 of 4.5
Plus Ownership disclosed not sourced0 of 1.5 yes1.5 of 1.5
Minus Domain bought from a previous owner yes−1.5 nono deduction (up to −1.5)
Minus On the market for less than a year yes · since 2026caps the score at 5.0 no · since 2022
Plus Typical yearly cost not sourced0 of 5 47.88 USD a year4.01 of 5
Plus IMAP/SMTP for any mail app IMAP/SMTP3 of 3 Via bridge app1.5 of 3
Plus Own domain not published0 of 2.5 yes2.5 of 2.5
Plus Aliases Unlimited1.5 of 1.5 Limited0.75 of 1.5
Plus Platform ratings no0 of 5 partly3.2 of 5
Basics
Apps (differs)
web, Android onionmail.org checked 7 Nov 2026
web, iOS, Android, Windows, macOS, Linux proton.me checked 16 Nov 2026
Free plansame for all
Yes onionmail.org checked 7 Nov 2026
Yes protonvpn.com checked 18 Nov 2026
Money-back guarantee (differs)
not applicable onionmail.org checked 7 Nov 2026
30 protonvpn.com checked 18 Nov 2026
Anonymity
Sign-up needs (differs)
only a username onionmail.org checked 7 Nov 2026
an existing e-mail address proton.me checked 18 Nov 2026
Sign-up over Tor/VPN (differs)
allowed onionmail.org checked 7 Nov 2026
allowed, with an extra check (phone, payment or review) proton.me checked 18 Nov 2026
ID check (differs)
an ID check on suspicion onionmail.org checked 7 Nov 2026
no ID check proton.me checked 17 Nov 2026
Login IPs keptsame for all
not published onionmail.org checked 7 Nov 2026
not published proton.me checked 17 Nov 2026
Mailbox location (differs)
not published onionmail.org checked 12 Nov 2026
Germany, Norway, Switzerland proton.me checked 15 Nov 2026
Data handed out without a court order (differs)
Yes onionmail.org checked 10 Nov 2026
No proton.me checked 17 Nov 2026
Data shared with third parties (differs)
not published onionmail.org checked 12 Nov 2026
No proton.me checked 17 Nov 2026
Policy on authority requests publishedsame for all
Yes onionmail.org checked 10 Nov 2026
Yes proton.me checked 13 Nov 2026
ID on demand in the terms (differs)
No onionmail.org checked 10 Nov 2026
not published proton.me checked 13 Nov 2026
Encryption
Stored mail (differs)
encrypted with keys the provider holds onionmail.org checked 7 Nov 2026
zero-access encrypted, unreadable for the provider proton.me checked 19 Nov 2026
End-to-end encryption (differs)
OpenPGP onionmail.org checked 7 Nov 2026
end-to-end between users, OpenPGP, password-protected messages proton.me checked 19 Nov 2026
Encrypted subject lines (differs)
not published onionmail.org checked 12 Nov 2026
No proton.me checked 16 Nov 2026
Open-source apps (differs)
not published onionmail.org checked 12 Nov 2026
Yes proton.me checked 19 Nov 2026
Post-quantum encryptionsame for all
Yes onionmail.org checked 7 Nov 2026
Yes proton.me checked 18 Nov 2026
Control & account risk
Abuse complaints (differs)
complaints reviewed before action onionmail.org checked 7 Nov 2026
suspension on complaint proton.me checked 13 Nov 2026
Mailbox exportsame for all
Yes onionmail.org checked 7 Nov 2026
Yes proton.me checked 16 Nov 2026
Inactive accounts deletedsame for all
inactive free accounts deleted onionmail.org checked 7 Nov 2026
inactive free accounts deleted proton.me checked 13 Nov 2026
Termination without notice (differs)
not published onionmail.org checked 12 Nov 2026
Yes proton.me checked 13 Nov 2026
Account security
Two-factor login (differs)
not published onionmail.org checked 12 Nov 2026
an authenticator app, security keys proton.me checked 18 Nov 2026
Features
Mail in other apps (differs)
IMAP and SMTP onionmail.org checked 7 Nov 2026
a bridge app proton.me checked 19 Nov 2026
Own domain (differs)
not published upgradeplan.onionmail.org checked 12 Nov 2026
Yes proton.me checked 19 Nov 2026
Aliases (differs)
unlimited upgradeplan.onionmail.org checked 7 Nov 2026
limited proton.me checked 19 Nov 2026
Storage (differs)
5 upgradeplan.onionmail.org checked 7 Nov 2026
15 proton.me checked 19 Nov 2026
Payment
Pay with (differs)
BTC, ETH, XMR onionmail.org checked 7 Nov 2026
BTC protonvpn.com checked 18 Nov 2026
Payment chains (differs)
not published onionmail.org checked 12 Nov 2026
Bitcoin protonvpn.com checked 18 Nov 2026
Other payment methods (differs)
card onionmail.org checked 7 Nov 2026
card, PayPal, cash by mail, bank transfer protonvpn.com checked 18 Nov 2026
Prices
Price per month (differs)
not applicable upgradeplan.onionmail.org checked 7 Nov 2026
4.99 USD proton.me checked 19 Nov 2026
Price per year
unknown
29.88 USD promotion, no end date stated proton.me checked 15 Nov 2026 , regular 47.88 USD proton.me checked 19 Nov 2026
Lifetime pricesame for all
not applicable upgradeplan.onionmail.org checked 7 Nov 2026
not applicable proton.me checked 19 Nov 2026
Trust
Support channels (differs)
e-mail onionmail.org checked 12 Nov 2026
e-mail, tickets proton.me checked 16 Nov 2026

Values of the chosen variant; without a choice the entry variant (first in the provider's order).

Early warning

Watch both e-mail services

One mail when something changes at Onion Mail · Proton Mail: promotions and bonuses as well as warnings and incidents.

What do you want to receive?

You will first get a mail with a confirmation link.