Stiftung Warentest has compared 18 plans from ten consumer email providers, with privacy-focused German services taking the top places. A report on the results published on 11 November 2026 names Posteo as the overall winner with a score of 1.7, followed by Mailbox at 1.8 and Web.de Mail Plus at 2.4.
Four of the ten paid plans received a “good” overall rating and the other six were rated “satisfactory.” None of the eight free plans achieved a “good” rating.
Privacy accounted for 30 percent of the overall result, while usability accounted for 45 percent. The privacy assessment considered app data transmissions, basic protection of user data and support for end-to-end encryption methods such as PGP and S/MIME. Mailbox earned the best privacy score at 1.4.
The comparison included Apple, Google, Microsoft, GMX, Web.de, T-Online, Posteo, Mailbox, Tuta and Proton. The available report does not give individual scores for Proton or Tuta. It also highlights the legal exposure of US-based providers, noting that they can be required to give US authorities access to foreign customers’ accounts under certain conditions, without necessarily informing those customers.